Tuesday, March 10, 2015

Blog 5: Jazz as a Historical Discourse demonstrated by Miles Davis

             Miles Davis’ autobiography immerses the reader in the foundations of jazz and ultimately captures the ‘quintessential’ life of a jazz musician (from the public perspective, at least). The racial issues confronted within his writing expose the plight of many a black jazz musician prior to the civil rights movement. The predominately white uptown and black downtown performance venues juxtaposed with the polarizing classical and experiential realms of musical education that Davis describes provide a comprehensive view of jazz’s historical development during his tenure as one of jazz’s finest trumpetists.
            Davis draws out the idea that jazz developed during an era of heightened racial tension, which I assumed was a defining factor in the musical genre’s history. His description of the contradictory bebop environments in New York paints a clear picture of the context of conflict that jazz was embedded in.
            “So that’s the kind of world I was juggling when I first got to New York, both uptown and downtown. I mean I was juggling it with Juilliard, which was a whole other world from the one bebop played in. And Bird was the king of this whole scene, because he did so much of everything that world was about – like shooting heroin, fucking around with whores, borrowing money to support his heroin habit, all that shit. Bird did more weird shit that anybody I ever met” (Davis 73).
            Several aspects of jazz’s historical development that were unbeknownst to me come up in this excerpt from his autobiography detailing Bird’s life and the bebop community. First and foremost, Miles’ time among both the privileged Juilliard community and the underprivileged, crime-ridden world of Charlie Parker illustrates the duality of New York’s jazz scene. The tension between uptown and downtown transcended privilege and escalated to race, with whites and blacks competing for employment as musicians and for guaranteed entry as patrons. However, musical education is also addressed within Davis’ statements about the dual worlds of the jazz community.
            Two distinct styles of musical acquisition are assessed in Davis’ statement, embodied by his classical training at Juilliard and performance experience gleaned from Bird. The frequently incorrect assumption that jazz musicians garnered no classical education is combatted in his statement. Davis, clearly not fond of Juilliard’s teaching methods, contrasts the schooling experience directly with the dark world of Bird and bebop and perpetuates the sense of tension between advantaged and disadvantaged realms of jazz.

            In addition, the substance-abusing musician stereotype that can arise in discussions of jazz is confronted in this statement as well. Davis does not seem to directly combat the idea that musicians could fall into traps of crime and drug use. However, the story of his life itself seems to serve as a contradiction to the tragic ends met by his fellow jazz contemporaries. He seems neither to reinforce nor contradict the stereotype, making it difficult to gain a clear understanding of whether the climate was one of crime established by the bebop community or a climate of classicism established Juilliard.

Commented on Chase Racich's blog

Works Cited

Davis, M. (1989). Miles: The Autobiography. New York: Simon & Schuster.

Thursday, March 5, 2015

Blog Entry 4: The Intersection of Art and Community

Robin Kelley clearly believes communities are responsible for shaping the artistic styles that develop within them. The relationship between Thelonious Monk’s musical genius and the community he grew up in, San Juan Hill, is no exception. Monk’s genius was shaped by San Juan Hill’s racial diversity and subsequent diversity in musical disciplines. His raw skill was transfigured into a new form of musical genius by the neighborhood. Much like New York and jazz, Monk's music and the bebop community would not have developed in the same way independently (if at all). Jazz’s relationship to the community in Leimart Park was parallel to that of San Juan Hill, a cultural melting pot that fostered integration and produced collaboration in the face of racial turbulence.

            In the midst of his upbringing and musical education in San Juan Hill, Thelonious Monk’s racially transgressive ideology influenced his musical style that would come to be known as bebop. Monk’s everyday experiences with the many ethnicities of San Juan Hill led to his disillusionment toward civil rights issues. Monk justified his lack of involvement in the same manner: “There’s no reason why I should go through that Black Power shit right now. I guess everybody in New York had to do that, right? Because every block was a different town. It was mean all over New York, all the boroughs. Besides fighting the ofays, you had to fight each other. You go to the next block and you’re in another country” (Kelley 19). As a result of the community that nurtured him, Monk’s unconventional racial ideology came to fruition. The “melting pot of immigrants” residing in San Juan Hill transformed his views on racial discrimination, including his refusal to accept a strictly black-white discourse on race issues (Stewart, 24 February 2015). It is arguable that neighborhoods like San Juan Hill fused a variety of cultural traditions into an unreplicable form of jazz, evident in the statement: “Jazz is New York, man!” In order to transcend race’s role in jazz, the community created a genre of music bound together by dissonance and the avant-garde rather than African aesthetic roots and European marching melodies as mainstream forms of jazz had previously.

            Monk used his music, intentionally or not, to create an artistic community that determined musicians’ skill level based objectively on their ability to play rather than on their ethnicity. Bebop became “the most integrated form of jazz” as a result of Monk’s efforts to include anyone who could master it, regardless of race (Stewart, 24 February 2015). In place of racial tolerance and political advocacy that musicians like Billie Holiday had previously expressed in politically-charged songs like “Strange Fruit,” Monk’s crowd began practicing “tolerance for modernity, for dissonance in music, and for the avant-garde in art” (Stewart, 24 February 2015). The music united the musicians, not their racial backgrounds. In short: if you could play it, no discussion of race was necessary. Much like Minton’s became the home base for “bebop pioneers” to congregate each Monday for jam sessions, Leimert Park’s 5th Street Dick’s became a meeting place for Los Angeles jazz musicians and the local community in the 1990s (Kelley 70).

            Leimart Park’s relationship to the artists residing within in it after the race riots is parallel to that between San Juan Hill and bebop artists of the Beat Generation. Both areas were undergoing social change – San Juan Hill was experiencing tumultuous discrimination as civil rights issues came to a head in the United States post-WWII. Rodney King’s assault by the LAPD incited further racial tension in the 1990s. In both cases, a creative clique was born from the ashes of discrimination. The owner of 5th Street Dick’s, Richard Fulton, became a racially neutral figurehead for the Leimart Park community as Thelonious Monk once had for San Juan Hill and Minton’s. Fulton once stated, “We have a spot where people can see their culture, can come and touch their culture. Now that doesn't exclude anybody. What it does is invites you to enjoy my culture. Once you enjoy my culture, you automatically understand who I am other than what people tell you about who I am. At the end of the day all the world needs is a little harmony" (Toney). Fulton’s racially transgressive attitude echoes that of Monk, and the dissonant music created in both settings is contrasted by the harmonious nature of the community created in the wake of racial turmoil.
           
Commented on Chase Racich's blog

Works Cited

Kelley, R. (2009). Thelonious Monk: The Life and Times of an American Original. New York:      
           Simon & Schuster, Inc.
Stewart, Jeffrey. "History of Jazz." Class Lecture. UCSB. 24 Feb. 2015. Lecture.

Toney, A. A Coffee Company Called 5th Street Dick’s. KCET, 11 Apr. 2014. Web. 4 Mar. 2015.                    
< http://www.kcet.org/socal/departures/leimert-park/a-coffee-company-called-5th-
      street-dicks.html>.

Thursday, February 12, 2015

Blog 3: The Racial Discourse of the Swing Era

            The race dialogue that occurred in the wake of 1920s jazz precipitated and defined the relationship between jazz musicians, their critics, and society at large during the Swing Era of the 1930s. The dawn of the radio, a racially obscure form of enjoying music, propelled swing from a Harlem piano style to a mainstream genre of music. In addition, swing musicians became household names and were sought after for nationwide and potentially transatlantic performances. The competitive spirit that developed from white appropriation of a recently developed music genre with clear black origins and their subsequent mainstream success drew resentment for its hypocrisy and ultimately became the impetus for a racial discourse. Jazz critics became the primary sources for an explicit discussion of jazz in racial terms ranging in topics from the musicians’ skill to their political views. 

            Swing’s rise in the 30s is largely due to its dissemination to a vast amount of people over the airwaves. The radio’s popularity began in the 1920s and coincided with another genre that produced a batch of highly skilled musicians, jazz. Listeners were captivated, and during the Great Depression it was much easier to turn on the radio than to continuously buy records or, for that matter, to attend a live show at places like the Savoy or the Cotton Club. However, as a result of white patronage at the Cotton Club, white swing bands and white bandleaders were popping up in Harlem. “At a time when the swing industry was glutted with more bands than it could profitably sustain, blacks were the first to be pushed out” (Swing Changes, 122). Now, radio listeners found it difficult to distinguish the race of any given musician. Andy Kirk also noted the racially blind nature of radio, “Since they came to know us only by radio they didn’t know whether we were white or black” (Swing Changes, p. 124). The nationalization of the swing movement through radio would increase competition for radio time and ultimately create racial tensions.

            The discussion of race in relation to jazz happened as a result of the fierce levels of competition between black and white swing bands at the time. Black resentment of white appropriation reached new heights: “After 1935 white swing bands were playing a music that struck many listeners as indistinguishable from that of their black counterparts; indeed, white bands sometimes drew stronger audience responses than black ones, even from African-Americans” (Swing Changes, 122). Concerts held at the Savoy Ballroom in Harlem pitted white and black bandleaders like Benny Goodman and Chick Webb against each other, drawing out the racial differences in the music. Swing audiences were invested in the competition, meaning that the musicians essentially had to cater to what their listeners wanted. In some cases, these listeners vocalized their opinions in the form of critiques.


            These musical critiques, especially by the liberal-minded John Hammond, were embedded in a dialogue of inferiority. Talented African-American musicians were spoken of as exceptions and anomalies, intentionally or not the rhetoric of racism was still present. However, Hammond did speak out against Duke Ellington for straying away from race as a social issue. Hammond described Ellington as intentionally ignorant to the hardships of his race: “It would probably take a Granville Hicks or a Langston Hughes to describe the way he shuts his eyes to the abuses being heaped upon his race and his original class” (Swing Changes, p. 51). Ironically, Ellington’s attempt to popularize his music by appealing to white audiences in segregated clubs like the Cotton Club backfired when critics of jazz and swing established the race discourse.

Geoff Moore

Thursday, February 5, 2015

Blog Entry #2 (BLST14): New York Jazz

             Upon first glance, the distinct jazz styles of New York and Chicago seem parallel in their development. The cultural conditions for jazz’s establishment in both cities are almost identical. Black immigrants of the 1920s were escaping the discriminatory climate of the South, a racial condition that pushed them north into cities like New York and Chicago. The industrial economy and technological advances of the North offered stable chances at income for blacks that they could not receive elsewhere, either as day laborers or as recording artists. In addition, the influx of people created a vacuum for the consumption of entertainment, which Harlem jazz musicians filled with live performances and recordings.

            Harlem stride piano and big band jazz are emblems of 1920s New York jazz. Harlem stride piano combined the ingenuity of several key figures (James P. Johnson, Willie ‘The Lion’ Smith, and Fats Waller) with several piano styles including blues, ragtime, classical, and boogie woogie (Gioia 95). Piano was included among the rhythm section instruments, combined with three other instrumental sections, to create a traditional big band: saxophone, trumpet, trombone (Gioia 100). Big band jazz substituted the section for the soloist, a characteristic of Chicago jazz, to create an ensemble style that still elevated players with superior talent to stardom.

            In terms of importance to the tradition of jazz, New York served to popularize jazz as a mainstream form of music. Harlem in particular became the hub of creation and competition for Harlem stride pianists as well as a breeding ground for the big band style of jazz characteristic of New York. Slumming, “the consumption of black entertainment by an affluent white clientele,” propelled New York’s big band jazz to fame (Gioia 116). Prior to the 1920s and the Great Migration, upper and middle class black families were not interested in consuming ‘southern’ music, but more southerners immigrated to New York with a desire to hear music reminiscent of their hometowns.  Instead, the New York natives became involved in the intellectual movement known as Harlem Renaissance. Blacks of Harlem were engaging in literary and cultural debates while simultaneously struggling to survive in a slum. As Gioia puts it, “The Harlem Renaissance created an ideology, a cultural context for jazz. But the Harlem of rent parties and underground economies created music” (90). The rent parties created an outlet of expression for the Harlem stride pianists’ cutting contests, “jam sessions to outplay the participants,” and as an outlet for anyone to escape the constraints of Prohibition (Gioia 92). White-only nightclubs and dance halls in Harlem like the Cotton Club and Roseland Ballroom began to regularly employ jazz bands as a ‘party playlist’ of sorts for Prohibition.

            Though Duke Ellington is probably the most well-known among the roster of bandleaders at the Cotton Club and other segregated Harlem nightclubs, Fletcher Henderson was another influential New York jazz musician and composer employed by them. Employed initially by smaller integrated or black clubs like Club Alabam, Henderson landed a gig at the whites-only Roseland Ballroom. The ‘big’ aspect of the band is emphasized even in what he called his ensemble of musicians, his orchestra. He is remarkable for is ability to assemble a large group of well-known musicians, including Louis Armstrong, Don Redman, and Coleman Hawkins (Gioia 102). Henderson represents the culture of New York jazz because of his upbringing and familiarity with European classical music traditions, much like New York prior to the Great Migration. He defied his upbringing and popularized southern-inspired jazz styles among both integrated and segregated audiences, fully embracing the diversity communities of Harlem and New York. Henderson’s orchestra represents the high skill level and unique style of New York jazz musicians while exemplifying less discriminatory attitudes in its willingness to perform for the entire Harlem community.


Gioia, T. (2011). The History of Jazz. New York: Oxford University Press.

Cody Tarlow

Thursday, January 22, 2015

BLST Blog 1 (Emily Wettleson, 5 p.m. section): Origins of Jazz

            Jazz arguably would not have begun without the African Diaspora and its influence on the American South during the era of slavery. However, jazz was formed through syncretism: “the blending together of cultural elements that previously existed separately.” Jazz was born through an amalgam of African, European, and Mexican aesthetic traditions that converged in New Orleans.
            Enslaved blacks of New Orleans introduced elements of African music previously unheard on American soil. For example, their work songs (which were in time with the labor they performed) contained several African musical aesthetic traditions: call-and-response, social integration, spirituality, and imitation of the voice through African-style (percussive and string) instruments. Slaves also had a musical accompaniment for leisure, exemplified in the Congo Square dances, which the New Orleans City Council chose as the specific area for slave dances in 1817. Congo Square’s purpose was not to pass time during work, but to celebrate a day of leisure given to slaves every Saturday. Slaves soon began to adjust parts of American culture to suit their traditional African musical style through the alteration of Anglo hymns into sorrow songs or ‘spirituals.’ Spirituals introduced the quality of improvisation. In addition, spirituals introduced the most distinctive quality of New Orleans Jazz, a tendency to emphasize the collective sound of the band as opposed to that of an individual instrument. Later, Joe ‘King’ Oliver would use this notion frequently in songs by his Creole Jazz Band, ironically featuring the greatest soloist of jazz, Louis Armstrong. Songs of leisure, work, and spirituality combined with white displays of minstrelsy to spur the creation of blues, a slower, sadder forerunner of New Orleans music prior to the rise of jazz as a popular mainstream genre.
            New Orleans became a hub of activity in terms of financial as well as cultural productivity after the Louisiana Purchase during the Industrial Revolution. The diversity of New Orleans was now evident. Creole culture was established as the previous generations of French and Spanish settlers procreated with Whites and Blacks. Creoles, Blacks, and Whites were comingling in the red light district (Storyville) and exchanging music to create a new genre from an amalgam of all the cultures present. This diversity was a breeding ground for musical syncretism.
            The Civil War contradicted the tolerance of the Latin code, but the resurgence of jazz in New Orleans came with the 1884 World’s Industrial and Cotton Centennial Exposition. At this point, New Orleans was a center of trade and commerce, which justifies the frequent influx of people, both domestic and international. Mexico had a phenomenal display at the fair, including their National Band. Some of the Mexican musicians stayed, including Lorenzo Tio Sr. and Jr., and instructed many black jazz musicians in classical clarinet techniques, including the likes of Jelly Roll Morton. I believe that Mexican musicians were instrumental (ha…ha) in enhancing the quality of New Orleans jazz by instructing the locals in classical music technique and by introducing them to woodwind instruments. The collaboration of cultural forces including the Mexican immigrants propelled New Orleans jazz to another level of novelty.
           The brass band tradition along with the collectivist expression exhibited by New Orleans musicians is markedly different from the soloist-dominated works of jazz created in Chicago in the following decades. The diversity of New Orleans’ jazz reflects the diversity of its inhabitants. The cultural syncretism of New Orleans created a form of jazz unreplicated by any other city. However, I argue that the African diaspora and its aesthetic traditions were the most vital factor in the creation of jazz because it seemed to initiate it, rather than add to it, as the other groups of cultural influencers did.

Comment: William Fisher (http://dawillus.blogspot.com)
Although I do believe it is important to point out the Creoles' hesitance to accept their black lineage, I believe it was more than compulsory. I believe they consciously accepted the black sector of their identity when Louisiana's red light district, Storyville, became the center of jazz performance in New Orleans. Storyville was the poor part of New Orleans funded by crime and entertainment. Economically, New Orleans' District was becoming a stable place to be for a jazz musician. I believe many Creoles came to the district willingly in order to pursue a career in jazz. The best names in jazz performed in the district, playing among them would make becoming successful tremendously easier. By suddenly embracing their black heritage which they had previously neglected, they were able to make a notable foray into the New Orleans jazz scene.