Thursday, February 12, 2015

Blog 3: The Racial Discourse of the Swing Era

            The race dialogue that occurred in the wake of 1920s jazz precipitated and defined the relationship between jazz musicians, their critics, and society at large during the Swing Era of the 1930s. The dawn of the radio, a racially obscure form of enjoying music, propelled swing from a Harlem piano style to a mainstream genre of music. In addition, swing musicians became household names and were sought after for nationwide and potentially transatlantic performances. The competitive spirit that developed from white appropriation of a recently developed music genre with clear black origins and their subsequent mainstream success drew resentment for its hypocrisy and ultimately became the impetus for a racial discourse. Jazz critics became the primary sources for an explicit discussion of jazz in racial terms ranging in topics from the musicians’ skill to their political views. 

            Swing’s rise in the 30s is largely due to its dissemination to a vast amount of people over the airwaves. The radio’s popularity began in the 1920s and coincided with another genre that produced a batch of highly skilled musicians, jazz. Listeners were captivated, and during the Great Depression it was much easier to turn on the radio than to continuously buy records or, for that matter, to attend a live show at places like the Savoy or the Cotton Club. However, as a result of white patronage at the Cotton Club, white swing bands and white bandleaders were popping up in Harlem. “At a time when the swing industry was glutted with more bands than it could profitably sustain, blacks were the first to be pushed out” (Swing Changes, 122). Now, radio listeners found it difficult to distinguish the race of any given musician. Andy Kirk also noted the racially blind nature of radio, “Since they came to know us only by radio they didn’t know whether we were white or black” (Swing Changes, p. 124). The nationalization of the swing movement through radio would increase competition for radio time and ultimately create racial tensions.

            The discussion of race in relation to jazz happened as a result of the fierce levels of competition between black and white swing bands at the time. Black resentment of white appropriation reached new heights: “After 1935 white swing bands were playing a music that struck many listeners as indistinguishable from that of their black counterparts; indeed, white bands sometimes drew stronger audience responses than black ones, even from African-Americans” (Swing Changes, 122). Concerts held at the Savoy Ballroom in Harlem pitted white and black bandleaders like Benny Goodman and Chick Webb against each other, drawing out the racial differences in the music. Swing audiences were invested in the competition, meaning that the musicians essentially had to cater to what their listeners wanted. In some cases, these listeners vocalized their opinions in the form of critiques.


            These musical critiques, especially by the liberal-minded John Hammond, were embedded in a dialogue of inferiority. Talented African-American musicians were spoken of as exceptions and anomalies, intentionally or not the rhetoric of racism was still present. However, Hammond did speak out against Duke Ellington for straying away from race as a social issue. Hammond described Ellington as intentionally ignorant to the hardships of his race: “It would probably take a Granville Hicks or a Langston Hughes to describe the way he shuts his eyes to the abuses being heaped upon his race and his original class” (Swing Changes, p. 51). Ironically, Ellington’s attempt to popularize his music by appealing to white audiences in segregated clubs like the Cotton Club backfired when critics of jazz and swing established the race discourse.

Geoff Moore

1 comment:

  1. I thought this post was well organized and flowed really well. Your point about how audiences could not tell which bands were which race over the radio was interesting, and I agree that competitions between white and black bandleaders directly influenced the exacerbation of a tense racial dialogue. Similar Harlem "showdowns" in the 1920's primarily highlighted musical prowess of the individual, whereas in the 1930's they highlighted the musical prowess of each race, creating resentment between races.

    ReplyDelete