Robin Kelley clearly believes communities are responsible
for shaping the artistic styles that develop within them. The relationship
between Thelonious Monk’s musical genius and the community he grew up in, San
Juan Hill, is no exception. Monk’s genius was shaped by San Juan Hill’s racial
diversity and subsequent diversity in musical disciplines. His
raw skill was transfigured into a new form of musical genius by the neighborhood. Much like
New York and jazz, Monk's music and the bebop community would not have developed in the same way independently (if at all). Jazz’s
relationship to the community in Leimart Park was parallel to that of San Juan
Hill, a cultural melting pot that fostered integration and produced
collaboration in the face of racial turbulence.
In the
midst of his upbringing and musical education in San Juan Hill, Thelonious
Monk’s racially transgressive ideology influenced his musical style that would
come to be known as bebop. Monk’s everyday experiences with the many ethnicities
of San Juan Hill led to his disillusionment toward civil rights issues. Monk
justified his lack of involvement in the same manner: “There’s no reason why I
should go through that Black Power shit right now. I guess everybody in New
York had to do that, right? Because every block was a different town. It was
mean all over New York, all the boroughs. Besides fighting the ofays, you had to
fight each other. You go to the next block and you’re in another country”
(Kelley 19). As a result of the community that nurtured him, Monk’s
unconventional racial ideology came to fruition. The “melting pot of
immigrants” residing in San Juan Hill transformed his views on racial discrimination,
including his refusal to accept a strictly black-white discourse on race issues (Stewart, 24
February 2015). It is arguable that neighborhoods like San Juan Hill fused a
variety of cultural traditions into an unreplicable form of jazz, evident in
the statement: “Jazz is New York, man!” In order to transcend race’s role in
jazz, the community created a genre of music bound together by dissonance and
the avant-garde rather than African aesthetic roots and European marching
melodies as mainstream forms of jazz had previously.
Monk used
his music, intentionally or not, to create an artistic community that
determined musicians’ skill level based objectively on their ability to play
rather than on their ethnicity. Bebop became “the most integrated form of jazz”
as a result of Monk’s efforts to include anyone who could master it, regardless
of race (Stewart, 24 February 2015). In place of racial tolerance and political
advocacy that musicians like Billie Holiday had previously expressed in
politically-charged songs like “Strange Fruit,” Monk’s crowd began practicing
“tolerance for modernity, for dissonance in music, and for the avant-garde in
art” (Stewart, 24 February 2015). The music united the musicians, not their racial backgrounds. In short: if you could play it, no discussion of race
was necessary. Much like Minton’s became the home base for “bebop
pioneers” to congregate each Monday for jam sessions, Leimert Park’s 5th
Street Dick’s became a meeting place for Los Angeles jazz musicians and the
local community in the 1990s (Kelley 70).
Leimart
Park’s relationship to the artists residing within in it after the race riots is parallel to that between San Juan Hill and bebop artists
of the Beat Generation. Both areas were undergoing social change – San Juan
Hill was experiencing tumultuous discrimination as civil rights issues came to
a head in the United States post-WWII. Rodney King’s assault by the LAPD
incited further racial tension in the 1990s. In both cases, a creative clique was born from the ashes of discrimination. The owner of 5th
Street Dick’s, Richard Fulton, became a racially neutral figurehead for the
Leimart Park community as Thelonious Monk once had for San Juan Hill and
Minton’s. Fulton once stated, “We
have a spot where people can see their culture, can come and touch their
culture. Now that doesn't exclude anybody. What it does is invites you to enjoy
my culture. Once you enjoy my culture, you automatically understand who I am
other than what people tell you about who I am. At the end of the day all the world
needs is a little harmony" (Toney). Fulton’s racially transgressive
attitude echoes that of Monk, and the dissonant music created in both settings is contrasted by the harmonious nature of the community created in the wake of
racial turmoil.
Commented on Chase Racich's blog
Works Cited
Works Cited
Kelley, R. (2009). Thelonious Monk: The Life and Times of an
American Original. New York:
Simon & Schuster, Inc.
Simon & Schuster, Inc.
Stewart, Jeffrey. "History of Jazz." Class Lecture.
UCSB. 24 Feb. 2015. Lecture.
Toney, A. A Coffee Company
Called 5th Street Dick’s. KCET, 11 Apr. 2014. Web. 4 Mar. 2015.
< http://www.kcet.org/socal/departures/leimert-park/a-coffee-company-called-5th-
street-dicks.html>.
< http://www.kcet.org/socal/departures/leimert-park/a-coffee-company-called-5th-
street-dicks.html>.
I really enjoyed reading your piece. I liked how you tied in Thelonious monk and the owner of 5th Street dicks as the figure heads of a racially neutral music based community. I do disagree with you on the development of Bebop being unique to New York. I believe other towns such as Kansas City or Los Angeles could have just as easily crafted and produced Bebop if the musicians like Dizzy and Bird had chosen those towns over New York. Jazz evolves so quickly and effectively, it somehow would have escaped the Swing era.
ReplyDeleteThis is an interesting take on the relationship between Monk had with his community, one almost completely based on musical diversity irrespective of race. In his own way, Monk definitely drove integration by bringing together artists of all races to create the vibrant artistic community in San Juan Hill and through his race neutral take on music.
ReplyDelete